The greatest paneer I’ve ever had was at Manek Chowk, a crowded vegetarian road meals market in Ahmedabad, Gujarat, India. In between fried pakoras and pineapple cheese sandwiches, I discovered skewers of paneer tikka cooking over glowing, crimson sizzling charcoal. Large chunks of paneer have been marinated in spicy, garlicky yogurt and skewered with items of tomatoes and bell peppers. The paneer turned crispy and caramelized on the outdoors, whereas the inside was moist and milky. It was so good, I elbowed my approach again twice for extra.
If you’re not acquainted, paneer is a contemporary, non-melting cheese common on the Indian subcontinent. It’s fried into pakoras, cooked in saucy dishes like saag paneer and became desserts like syrupy rasgulla. I like that paneer is a chameleon, always reinventing itself. But up till just lately good paneer didn’t exist in the U.S. except you made it your self. It’s largely mass produced, with a rubbery texture and sufficient preservatives for a six-month shelf life. The extensively obtainable Nanak paneer from Canada, for instance, has no taste, to the level the place it makes you doubt it comprises dairy. It made me embarrassed on India’s behalf.
That’s why Oakland’s Sach Foods’ natural, small-batch paneer is such a creamy revelation. Founders and husband-wife group Tarush and Jasleen Agarwal are attempting to vary the paneer narrative. “Nothing creative has been done by other makers in what feels like decades,” Tarush Agarwal explains. “Our approach is different.” By providing a home made product utilizing minimal, high-quality elements beginning with natural grass-fed Jersey milk, they’re creating a brand new marketplace for high-end paneer whereas evolving the idea with flavored paneer.
Paneer sometimes has no taste, not even salt, and it’s flavored by no matter it cooks in. But Jasleen Agarwal grew up in New Delhi consuming it contemporary with salt and pepper, so their paneer is able to eat. It’s salted and comes in flavors like habanero and turmeric.
Paneer is historically made by curdling buffalo milk with an acid (lemon juice, vinegar or yogurt), then straining and urgent the curds for a couple of hours. The completed cheese may be minimize into chunks or slabs and received’t soften at excessive temperatures. There are regional variations, like tender Parsi topli paneer and Surti paneer, which are each set with rennet, however the agency type common in Punjab is the most well-known.
No one agrees on paneer’s origins. For a very long time in India, it was even thought-about taboo to separate the milk of a holy cow. Historian Ok.T. Achaya believes that paneer was launched by the Portuguese in the 1500s, together with chhena, paneer’s softer cousin. Others imagine it got here earlier from Iranian and Afghani rulers (the phrase paneer has Persian origins). But chef and cheese marketing consultant Aditya Raghavan thinks paneer has a good longer historical past. He discovered Indian texts that point out cheeselike merchandise made by heating milk and yogurt from the Kushan interval (second century, B.C.).
Growing up, Jasleen and Tarush (who grew up in Jamshedpur, a metropolis in japanese India) keep in mind paneer was both made at residence or bought from neighborhood shops that specialised in it, and it was solely good for a couple of days. Today, so much of paneer in India is made with a combination of buffalo and less-expensive cow’s milk. There can be mass-produced paneer from manufacturers like Amul and Mother Dairy.
In the U.S., paneer is usually created from cow’s milk, citric acid and thickening brokers. According to Amod Chopra, the proprietor of Vik’s Chaat and Market in Berkeley, it doesn’t come near the richness and chewiness of buffalo milk paneer made in India.
Vik’s began in 1987, and Chopra remembers first seeing packaged paneer being offered in the U.S. by an East Coast dairy in the 1980s. When Vik’s expanded right into a restaurant in 1989, it began making its personal paneer with cow’s milk and lemon juice (which it nonetheless does). Chopra says the market first offered further paneer from the restaurant, and that promoting do-it-yourself paneer was frequent for small Indian markets at the time. As Vik’s grew greater, it offered packaged paneer, and some years in the past it began importing frozen buffalo milk paneer from India and promoting it below the Vik’s label.
Despite the 300,000 Indian Americans in the Bay Area, it’s troublesome to seek out contemporary paneer right this moment. Around 2005, Cowgirl Creamery produced a Parsi-style cow’s milk paneer (tender and spreadable) for a couple of years utilizing a recipe by cookbook author Niloufer Ichaporia King.
Where to seek out Sach Foods paneer
Sach Foods sells its cheese on its web site, https://sachfoods.com/collections/summer-fresh, $7.99 every plus transport. Original taste, turmeric twist and spicy habanero are presently obtainable.
Also obtainable at Bi-Rite Market’s 18th Street and Divisadero places, Gus’s Community Market and Rainbow Grocery in San Francisco; the Cheese Board, Berkeley Bowl and Berkeley Bowl West in Berkeley; Market Hall and Piedmont Grocery in Oakland; Alameda Natural Grocery in Alameda; Good Earth Natural Foods in Fairfax and Mill Valley; Sigona’s Farmers Market in Redwood City and Palo Alto; and Bianchini’s Market in San Carlos and Portola Valley.
One of the causes the Agarwals ended up founding Sach Foods was as a result of as vegetarians, they each wanted high-protein snacks. Tarush is a marathon runner, and at the time, Jasleen was doing the keto weight loss plan. They liked consuming paneer in India, however stopped in the U.S. as a result of the high quality was horrible. “Paneer should be soft and creamy,” Jasleen says, “but here I can’t snack on it because it’s hard and needs to sit in hot water to make it softer. It’s just not the same product.”
She began making her personal paneer at residence and experimenting with flavors like Thai curry, mint chutney and basil-jalapeño. She joined a industrial kitchen in 2018, and after getting nice suggestions, she and Tarush launched Sach Foods (sach means trustworthy in Hindi) in October 2018. As first-generation immigrants with no meals enterprise background and no monetary backing, they are making it work by means of self-funding, retaining their day jobs in the tech sector and renting out half of their residence on Airbnb and their automobile on Getaround.
It hasn’t been straightforward. They needed to persuade potential producers of their product that there was a marketplace for high-end paneer when nothing prefer it existed. At pop-ups and meals demos, they stretch the restrict of what Americans assume paneer can do. Slices of paneer changed the bread in bruschetta, and so they made a Baja taco with battered and fried turmeric paneer, cabbage slaw and cilantro crema. On their web site and Instagram web page, you’ll see saag paneer reinvented as toast, their habanero taste paneer sliced, battered and fried into “fries,” their mint chutney taste used as protein in a vegetarian Thai papaya salad, or grilled like a burger and served in a bun with chile-avocado crema.
“Consumers are familiar with the concept of a cheese board, but not with paneer,” Tarush says. “Our goal is to position it as modern, innovative … with diverse applications.”
The paneer is now obtainable in 50 shops in the Bay Area and Los Angeles and several other eating places, together with August 1 Five, Rooh and Greens. In the future, they hope to promote paneer merchandise like burger patties or fries and to introduce new flavors reminiscent of rose and cardamom, which might work properly with desserts.
Their enterprise took successful with the COVID-19 pandemic as their restaurant companions closed down, however one factor that helped was having a number of distribution channels, together with direct to prospects; on-line gross sales truly elevated fifteenfold between January and April.
The Agarwals know they couldn’t have made it this far with out these first shops and eating places that took an opportunity on them, many of which are now getting meals to the group whereas compromising their very own well being.
“It’s an incredible and very powerful movement, and those are the same partners who have helped us as entrepreneurs,” Tarush says. “We are so grateful to our community.”
Leena Trivedi-Grenier is a contract author residing in the Bay Area. Email: firstname.lastname@example.org Instagram: @leenaeats